Logo
Home
>
Investments
>
Take profits when goals are met, not when emotions peak

Take profits when goals are met, not when emotions peak

08/12/2025
Maryella Faratro
Take profits when goals are met, not when emotions peak

Every investor faces a pivotal decision point: when to sell an asset and convert gains into real returns.

Too often, this moment is hijacked by gut feelings rather than grounded in strategy, leading to missed opportunities or unnecessary losses.

In this article, you will discover how to harness the power of predefined profit targets with clear thresholds and free yourself from the emotional rollercoaster of fear and greed.

Understanding profit-taking and why it matters

Profit-taking is more than just the act of selling an investment after its value climbs—it’s a proactive risk management tool.

By defining exit points in advance, investors can crystallize gains, rebalance portfolios, and safeguard their capital against sudden reversals.

Consider two broad asset classes: those with fluctuating values, like stocks and real estate, and stable-value vehicles, such as savings accounts.

Real-world example: purchasing shares for CHF 100,000 and watching them rise to CHF 125,000 offers a enticing CHF 25,000 profit—but only if you commit to taking it.

Common objective profit-taking techniques

Several proven methods allow you to remove emotion from your trading by following a set of rules.

  • Fixed target selling: define a price level or percentage gain to trigger a sale automatically.
  • Partial scaling out: liquidate portions of your position at different milestones to lock in incremental gains.
  • Portfolio rebalancing: trim top performers periodically to maintain your desired risk profile.
  • Trailing stop-loss orders: set a dynamic stop level that rises with the market and secures a floor on gains.

Implementing these tactics fosters a systematic exit strategy free of emotion, ensuring you stick to your plan when markets sway.

Fixed targets bring discipline, while scaling out lets you balance between locking in profits and staying involved in future upside.

Rebalancing acts as a built-in profit-taking mechanism, and trailing stop-loss orders automate protection against sudden downturns.

Why emotions derail your strategy

Financial markets are driven by human nature, and emotions like fear and greed often dictate trading behavior.

When stocks skyrocket, greed whispers that you should hold on for even greater returns—until the next downward spiral arrives.

Similarly, a rapid sell-off can trigger panic, prompting an emotional exit at the worst possible moment.

Studies reveal that investors guided by sentiment underperform disciplined participants by several percentage points annually.

Emotion-driven decisions lead to premature selling in a panic or excessive holding during euphoric rallies, both detrimental to long-term growth.

A cautionary tale: when emotion takes the wheel

Meet Emma, a retail investor who bought into a popular tech stock at CHF 50 per share.

As the price soared to CHF 75, she ignored her plan to sell at 20% gains, convinced that the rally would last indefinitely.

When the stock peaked at CHF 90, Emma finally succumbed to greed and decided to hold on “just a little longer.”

Two weeks later, the price plunged back to CHF 60, wiping out her unrealized gains and triggering panic selling below her initial buy price.

This scenario exemplifies how allowing emotion to override a systematic exit strategy can turn profitable trades into painful losses.

Behavioral insights: bridging research and real-life outcomes

Behavioral finance uncovers cognitive biases that skew our judgment. Loss aversion makes losses feel twice as painful as gains feel pleasurable.

Recency bias causes us to overweight recent outcomes, leading to erratic shifts in strategy after a few market swings.

Academic research on large investor samples found that rule-based approaches outperformed discretionary trading by up to 3% per year.

Warren Buffett encapsulates this wisdom: “Games are won by players who focus on the playing field – not by those whose eyes are glued to the scoreboard.”

His advice points to the power of discipline over impulse in cultivating enduring wealth.

Implementing goal-driven exits: step-by-step guide

Shifting your mindset from reactive to proactive is crucial. Embrace the idea that a sold position is not a lost opportunity but a responsible conclusion of a defined strategy.

  1. Define clear profit goals: set realistic targets based on research and risk tolerance, e.g. a 30% gain on core holdings and a 50% gain on speculative positions.
  2. Automate your exits: use take-profit and stop-loss orders to enforce your plan without hesitation.
  3. Scale out methodically: sell 25% of your position at 50% gains, another 25% at 75% gains, etc., to secure incremental profits.
  4. Rebalance with discipline: conduct quarterly or semiannual portfolio reviews to trim outperformers and maintain target asset weights.
  5. Review and adapt regularly: adjust goals only when justified by changes in fundamentals or your personal situation, not short-term market swings.

Maintain a trading journal to log every exit and its outcome. Reviewing your journal uncovers patterns of emotion-driven mistakes and reinforces your strengths.

By following this framework, you’ll build a resilient, emotion-resistant trading plan that enhances your chances of compounding returns.

Practical example: executing a profit-taking framework

Imagine you invest CHF 100,000 in a diversified stock basket with a 20% target return.

As the portfolio climbs to CHF 120,000, you sell 30% of the position, realizing CHF 6,000 in gains.

The remaining CHF 84,000 stays invested, allowing you to benefit from potential further appreciation.

If the market falls 10% from its peak, a trailing stop-loss order on the remaining holdings executes automatically, protecting additional gains.

Conclusion: the path to consistent gains

Profit-taking is a disciplined habit, not a reactionary impulse.

By anchoring your decisions to objective profit-taking strategies, you free yourself from the anxiety and overconfidence that plague many market participants.

Let the clarity of your plan guide you: set goals, automate triggers, and review methodically—never letting emotional extremes dictate your fate.

Start today by defining your next profit target and setting your first automated exit order. Give yourself the gift of clarity and peace of mind with each trade.

Over time, these consistent actions compound into significant wealth, stress reduction, and growth—not just in your portfolio, but in your confidence as an investor.

Maryella Faratro

About the Author: Maryella Faratro

Maryella Faratro